Japanese Earthquake Rocks The Markets

Published in Investing on 15 March 2011

With the Nikkei crashing 11% overnight, what can we learn from the 1995 Kobe earthquake?

Since the earthquake off Japan's coast last Friday, the news has been full of catastrophic stories.

Each day brings new horrors, including an ever-greater loss of life, plus the race to prevent further explosions at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant.

When markets quake

No doubt the global community will do what it can to assist Japan and its people in the aftermath of this horrific tragedy.

In the meantime, worries about the colossal cost of cleaning up after the quake and tsunami have shattered the Japanese stock market. As the world's third-largest economy (after the US and China), what hurts Japan tends to hurt the global economy as a whole.

The Nikkei nose-dives

Here's how Japan's leading stock-market index, the Nikkei 225, has crashed since tremors rocked Japan in the final hour of trading on Friday:

DateNikkei 225ChangeChange (%)
Three days



On Monday alone, the 6.2% slide in the Nikkei wiped $287 billion from the value of its 225 members. However, following a third explosion at the Fukushima plant, nervous investors rushed to sell risky assets, causing a near-11% decline in the Nikkei 225 on Tuesday.

At one point last night, things were even worse, as the Japanese market bounced back before closing. Prior to this rebound, the Nikkei hit a low of 8,228, down 1,393 points (14.5%) on Monday's close!

This is the index's lowest level since 28 April 2009, and the first time the Nikkei has dropped below the 9,000 level since 1 September last year. Clearly, investors are terrified about the earthquake's financial implications for Japan, as well as its human cost.

Lessons from Kobe

As an avid student of financial history, I heard the news of the quake and immediately thought of a similar event: the Kobe earthquake of 17 January 1995.


Have you ever wanted to learn more about dividend investing?

Todd Wenning, The Motley Fool’s foremost Dividend Investing expert,
will be hosting a LIVE CHAT on The Motley Fool website on Friday 18th March.

Todd will be explaining how you could generate superior share income by
investing in dividend-paying shares -- this is your chance to hear Todd’s secrets
and ask him any questions you have. CLICK HERE to register your interest

Although the Kobe quake (magnitude 6.8) was much less severe than the latest quake (magnitude 9.0), it caused widespread damage. The 1995 quake killed nearly 6,500 people and caused damage of ten trillion yen, or a 40th of Japan's gross domestic product (GDP) at the time.

Of course, the Kobe earthquake also caused the Nikkei to plunge -- but nothing like as steeply as it has in the past three trading sessions. Here's what happened in the immediate aftermath of Kobe:

The Kobe slump

DateNikkei 225ChangeChange (%)
Four days



As you can see, the market reaction to Kobe was quite muted at first, but later led to a 1,055-point dive in a single day. This equates to a 5.6% drop, versus Tuesday's 10.6% fall.

Thus, broadly speaking, the post-quake pattern of 1995 was much less panicked than that seen since Friday. Then again, there were no nuclear accidents in the aftermath of Kobe -- and nothing frightens investors more than the N-word.

Nevertheless, the 17.5% decline in the Nikkei since Friday suggests that Mr Market may have over-reacted, and we could see a strong relief rally once control is restored at the Fukushima nuclear facility.

A rogue trader collapses

The market reaction to the Kobe quake was worsened by the actions of one man: infamous British rogue trader Nicholas 'Nick' Leeson.

As a derivatives broker for Britain's oldest merchant bank, Barings Bank, Leeson was a leading trader of equity futures on the Tokyo and Singapore exchanges. Alas, when Leeson's trades produced losses, he hid them in an error account numbered 88888 (considered a very lucky number in China).

Like a bad gambler chasing his losses, Leeson kept increasing the size of his bets, borrowing tens of millions of pounds a day from Barings' treasury department in London. When the Nikkei fell more than 1,000 points on 23 January 2005, Leeson's Ponzi scheme finally blew up.

When the dust had settled, Leeson had racked up debts of $1.4 billion, forcing the once-proud Barings to sell itself for £1 to leading Dutch bank ING. Ouch!

The good news is that, after its initial volatility, the Nikkei gradually crept back towards its pre-Kobe levels (although this was far too late for Leeson). On 7 December 1995, the Nikkei finally notched up its first post-quake gain, 11 months after Kobe.

More market meltdowns?

Looking beyond the human tragedy, there must be some hope for the Japanese economy and its resilient, hard-working, inventive people. For example, the huge post-quake rebuilding effort should boost the fortunes of Japanese construction and heavy-equipment firms, as happened in 1995.

Also, it's worth noting that Kobe was a major economic region in Japan, whereas the latest quake mostly devastated coastal areas, with the tsunami washing over large tracts of farmland, rather than factories.

No doubt the Bank of Japan (BoJ) will do what it can to cushion Japanese shares and its currency against further falls. On Monday, it made Y21.8 trillion ($265 billion) of extra liquidity available to financial institutions, as well as doubling its quantitative-easing (asset-buying) programme to Y10 trillion.

Nevertheless, the BoJ must act swiftly and do even more to stimulate economic growth, especially with the country facing the twin headwinds of deflation and a strong yen. Similarly, the Japanese government is poised to announce an emergency stimulus package aimed at shoring up the economy.

The best way to buy into Japan

An old investment adage says, "Buy when there's blood on the streets". Given the current panic in the Far East, this could be adapted to "Buy when there are radioactive gases in the air."

Thus, with the Nikkei having fallen by more than a sixth, what can bold or contrarian investors do to buy while prices are depressed?

You could try catching a few 'falling knives' -- the Japanese shares which have crashed most since Friday. However, this strategy often leaves investors nursing cut fingers. A lower-risk approach would be to buy into Japanese index-tracking funds, which enable you to spread your risk across many companies at low cost.

Even better, you could look into Japanese investment trusts (listed investment companies with tradable shares) whose shares are trading on wide discounts to their net asset values. When the Land of the Rising Sun bounces back from this tragedy, so too will these trusts.

Finally, with the March 2009 bull market now two years old, any further nuclear crises at Fukushima could trigger more meltdowns by Mr Market. So, watch this space!

*** FREE REPORT - Get Defensive With Dividends ***

For long-term investors, the best defence is a good offence. Never mind what the overall market is doing -- position your portfolio correctly and you could protect your investments for the long term.

Click here to claim your FREE Motley Fool special report.

Share & subscribe


The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

UncleEbenezer 15 Mar 2011 , 1:16pm

I'm more bothered by the prospect of a backlash against nuclear energy. Other sources available on a large scale are so much more harmful. Not to mention supply issues ...

shundeez 15 Mar 2011 , 2:02pm

Catching falling knives is not in my strategy. I tried it with BP and got badly burned. I'll stick to finding value the foolish way.

BarrenFluffit 15 Mar 2011 , 3:10pm

Investment trusts: Looking at this linked table one might ask "wide discounts?"
However its a function of the lag in data. Individual pages show wider discounts.

tru2me 15 Mar 2011 , 3:31pm

I'm more bothered by the prospect of a backlash against nuclear energy.

Agree UncleEbenezer, but isn't it more to do with building nuclear plant(s) on naturally volatile faults along the earth's crust. Tectonic plate issues.
Maybe the position of Japan geographically leaves the country with little choice.

CunningCliff 15 Mar 2011 , 3:31pm

Yes, BarrenFluffit, the discount calculations are lagging a few days behind the market. Clearly, they are not being kept up to date with events! ;0)


archibold 15 Mar 2011 , 5:08pm


Are you sure Nick was running a Ponzi scheme? More like unauthorised trading from what I recall (similar to Jerome Kerviel). He wasn't taking in assets to pay out existing investors (what I've understood to be a ponzi scheme).

Sidekicker101 15 Mar 2011 , 6:29pm

Catching falling knives is not in my strategy. I tried it with BP and got badly burned. I'll stick to finding value the foolish way.

You have to wait for a bottom and then look for retraces to hold. Oh sorry, people don;t like charts on this blog.

eccyman 15 Mar 2011 , 10:04pm

I know the green (ie anti-capitalist lobby) will make a meal of the incident in Japan. I look at things from a different angle

(1) Three mile Island occurred in 1979, Chernobyl in 1986, Fukishima in 2011. Nuclear accidents are getting less frequent.

(2) The fact a reactor can take a richter 9.0 earthquake, a tsunami then an explosion and remain intact suggests they're robust.

(3) We're all subject to background radiation all the time. Indeed there's a town in Iran called Ramsar. It's more radio-active than Chernobyl, yet it's a holiday resort.

browntrout74 15 Mar 2011 , 10:59pm

Falling knives or hot rods?

Bought into this today down 18% at one point, finished down 12% ETFX WNA Global Nuclear Energy Fund (NUKE)

CunningCliff 16 Mar 2011 , 10:45am

Hi archibold,

Yes -- in a literal sense, a Ponzi scheme is a bogus investment scheme where one takes in money from new investors in order to pay fake 'returns' to existing investing, as per Charles Ponzi's famous scam of 1920, see:

However, these days, 'Ponzi' is journalistic shorthand for any unsustainable or plain bonkers investment, such as Leeson's 88888 scam, which was nothing short of gambling the firm!


CunningCliff 16 Mar 2011 , 2:32pm

On the subject of Japanese 'falling knives', take a look at the share price of TEPCO (Tokyo Electric Power Company), the operator of the crippled nuclear power plant, since the quake:


Mon: -23.6%
Tue: -24.7%
Wed: -24.6%



Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.