Here's How Europe Turned Into A Train Wreck

Published in Investing on 30 April 2012

We take a look back at the mess that has become the eurozone.

A version of this article originally appeared on our US site,

Wrapping your head around the European debt crisis can be quite a headache, and all that commotion can be hard to follow at times. What with austerity packages, government strikes and bond yields, it feels likes there's no end in sight.

Just in the last couple of weeks, 10-year bond yields in Spain approached 6% and the country declared itself officially in a recession; France took a step closer to electing a socialist president sceptical of austerity; and the Dutch government fell apart over budget cuts that would bring its deficit under 3% of GDP, as the eurozone mandates.

How it all began

International banking collapses often lead to sovereign debt crises, and this time around was no different. The Great Recession and the destabilisation of financial markets pushed European deficits to unsustainable levels, and the shared currency put a further bind on the more profligate countries as they could not pump more money into their economies nor could they let their currencies float to encourage exports.

In 2008, only Greece and Ireland had deficit-to-GDP ratios above 6% -- twice the EU's limit -- but by 2009 nine EU countries broke the 6% threshold, with Greece the biggest offender at 15.8%. In October of that year, new Prime Minister George Papandreou revealed that his predecessor had been understating the deficit for years. Credit downgrades soon followed, and government officials and union members began striking against austerity measures such as an increase in the retirement age. In May 2010, Greece received its first round of bailout loans, totalling $152 billion from the eurozone and IMF.

We can see the Greek crisis play out through the lens of stocks like the National Bank of Greece (NYSE: NBG.US) and DryShips (NASDAQ: DRYS.US). The National Bank of Greece traded above $40 before Papandreou revealed the deficit bubble and has since sunk to near $2, while the Greek shipper traded above $100 before the financial crisis and now goes for about $3. Greek stocks experienced none of the recovery that other markets did after the financial crisis, and the Athens Stock Exchange Index is now worth just 15% of what it was five years ago.

Elsewhere on the continent...

While Greece was spiralling out of control, foreboding signs from Spain, Portugal and Ireland appeared in the form of contracting growth rates, bank bailouts and debt downgrades. Throughout 2010, the euro continued to drop to lows not seen in several years, and in November, Ireland received an 85 billion euro bailout from the EU and IMF and passed the country's strictest budget in history.

In May 2011, Portugal became the third eurozone country to receive a bailout, getting 78 billion euros, and during that summer Greece received its second round of emergency loans, this time for $157 billion. Soon after, yields on Spanish and Italian bonds jumped, and the European Central Bank announced it would buy those bonds to help control borrowing rates. Fears of a double-dip recession abounded in September after data showed the eurozone's private sector declined for the first time in two years.

In January 2012, after several rounds of talks failed to produce effective results, the S&P downgraded the debts of nine EU countries as well as the eurozone bailout fund. Fears of falling into another recession raged in the proceeding months as data showed negative growth in the continent and a record-high eurozone unemployment rate in March. The following week Greece received a third bailout of 130 billion euros, and in April, Italian and Spanish bond rates rose again, stoking new fears about their countries' solvency.

How we stand today

Attention in recent weeks has focused on the struggling Spanish economy, which recently dove back into recession due in large part to its record high unemployment rate of 23.6%, the highest in the eurozone. Investors in Spanish heavyweights like Telefonica (NYSE: TEF.US) and Banco Santander (NYSE: STD.US) have felt the pain, as shares of both companies have been sliced in half over the past year. Unlike in other suffering eurozone countries, which became victims of their own debt burdens, a housing bubble was central to Spain's epidemic as home prices grew 44% from 2004 to 2008. Once the bubble burst, the construction sector fell apart with it, and now the government is trying to fill the huge deficit created by the jump in unemployment benefits and the loss of tax revenues.

On the whole, the eurozone seems to be caught in a macroeconomic Catch-22. Further austerity measures may jeopardise economic growth, but an economic stimulus, as US Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner and others have called for, will only add to the debt rolls. A looming demographic crunch also awaits the continent if it can make it past the debt crisis. Low birthrates and generous entitlements are likely to further constrain budgets as some European countries' populations should start falling by 2015.

Where do we go now?

Now may be Europe's moment of truth. Much praise can be heaped on a region that's gone from twice laying waste to itself in the first half of the 20th century to joining under the same currency and collectively forming the world's biggest economy. In the end, though, the current struggle to stay together may prove as formidable as any other challenge the continent's faced.

In the days to come, elections in France, the Netherlands and Greece will help clarify the next steps in the debt crisis. French Socialist candidate Francois Hollande narrowly won the first round of presidential elections and favours growth-oriented measures over more austerity. The French will go to the polls on 6 May to select their president. Greece will also vote in a new government the same day to replace the interim administration that followed former Prime Minister Papandreou, who was pressured out last year by France and Germany. Poll watchers expect a coalition government to result. Elections in the Netherlands will also likely take place soon, after its government fell apart Monday following disagreements over budget cuts.

Finally, as Spain teeters, some have suggested that it may need a cash injection, which would drain the eurozone bailout fund since Spain is much larger than any other country that's received a bailout.

For now, in this age of globalisation all eyes remain on Europe.

For help trying to grow and preserve your wealth, start your 30-day free trial to Motley Fool Share Advisor today. You'll get immediate access to what we believe are the best shares you can buy today, complete with our in-depth analysis and ongoing coverage.  

Further investment opportunities:

Share & subscribe


The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

spyknife 17 May 2012 , 12:07pm

In my opinion the Greek government is the foundation to this cancer.
And Germany is the cure ! If the Greeks cannot govern themselves it is only fair they let the Germans do it.If I was Angela Merkel I would order German troops onto Greek soil asap.And then auction the Greek islands to the highest bidders.
I cannot believe Greece has become todays Lehman Brothers.

sippquixote 17 May 2012 , 2:38pm

Mr Cameron has just awarded Santander Bank the contract to run the payments to/from HMRC.
I can't think of a wiser move in order to demonstrate his confidence in the Euro and the Eurozone.

Don't panic, the Prime Minister is sure that everything will be alright.

revcbr 05 Jun 2012 , 7:52pm

@ sippquixote

I'm no fan of the cameroon. However, he may be wiser here than you think. Santander UK (formerly Abbey) is, as far as I understand, a totally independent organisation to Santander, Spain. Others have assured me that there is [b]no[b] mechanism by which funds from Santander UK may be transferred to Santander, Spain. It is, in fact, reckoned to be one of the safer financial institutions on the UK!

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as as opposed to

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.