Is Carnival The Ultimate Retirement Share?

Published in Company Comment on 11 December 2012

Will shares in Carnival (LSE: CCL) help you build a FTSE-beating retirement fund?

The last five years have been tough for those in retirement. Portfolio valuations have been hammered and annuity rates have plunged. There's no sign of things improving anytime soon, either, as the eurozone and the UK economy look set to muddle through at best for some years to come.

A great way of protecting yourself from the downturn, however, is by building your retirement fund with shares of large, well-run companies that should grow their earnings steadily over the coming decades. Over time, such investments ought to result in rising dividends and inflation-beating capital growth.

In this series, I'm tracking down the UK large-caps that have the potential to beat the FTSE 100 (UKX) over the long term and support a lower-risk income-generating retirement fund (you can see the companies I've covered so far on this page).

Today, I'm going to take a look at Carnival (LSE: CCL) (NYSE: CCL.US), the cruise ship operator whose brands include P&O Cruises, Cunard and Costa Cruises.

Carnival vs. FTSE 100

Let's start with a look at how Carnival has performed against the FTSE 100 over the last 10 years:

Total Returns2007200820092010201110 yr trailing avg
Carnival-11.6%-28.0%41.5%40.8%-26.6%6.9%
FTSE 1007.4%28.3%27.3%12.6%-2.2%8.1%

Source: Morningstar

(Total return includes both changes to the share price and reinvested dividends. These two ingredients combined are what make it possible for equity portfolios to regularly outperform cash and bonds over the long term.)

Carnival's 10-year average trailing total return suggests that its performance has been quite closely matched to the FTSE 100 over the longer term -- and the 21.8% total return the firm has delivered so far in 2012 is all the more impressive when you remember that the year got off to a bad start, with the high-profile shipwreck of Carnival's Costa Concordia cruise ship in January.

What's the score?

To help me pinpoint suitable investments, I like to score companies on key financial metrics that highlight the characteristics I look for in a retirement share. Let's see how Carnival shapes up:

ItemValue
Year founded1972
Market cap£5.3bn
Net debt£5.7bn
Dividend Yield2.5%
5 year average financials
Operating margin17.3%
Interest cover6.5x
EPS growth-2.6%
Dividend growth-0.5%
Dividend cover4.1x

Source: Morningstar, Reuters, Carnival

Here's how I've scored Carnival on each of these criteria:

CriteriaCommentScore
LongevityCarnival is still quite young.2/5
Performance vs. FTSEFairly respectable, although not quite index-beating.3/5
Financial strengthSomewhat reliant on debt -- negative cash flow for four of the last five years.3/5
EPS growthAdjusted earnings remain lower than in 2007.2/5
Dividend growthCuts in 2009 and 2010 mean that this year's dividend is lower than in 2007.3/5
Total: 13/25

Carnival's score of 13/25 is pretty bad and suggests that the cruise ship company would not make a good retirement share. So what are the problems?

Firstly, Carnival's dividend history was sabotaged when it slashed the total dividend during the financial crisis. This year's dividend is roughly at 2006 levels and is 40% lower than it was in 2007, but I scored Carnival 3/5 in the dividend growth category because until 2007, it had increased its dividend every year since 1989 -- a good record. Carnival's lack of earnings growth and reliance on debt funding is more of a concern to me, suggesting that the business struggles to generate enough cash and could easily be forced to cancel its dividends once more, in the event of another sharp downturn.

What's more, although Carnival's share price has recovered strongly this year, brokers' pre-tax profit forecasts for 2012 and 2013 are lower than the company's pre-tax profits in 2011, suggesting they expect the cost pressures and decline in ticket pricing that has been experienced this year to continue into 2013. Unsurprisingly, Carnival's Chairman and CEO, Micky Arison, disagrees with this assessment and in the company's third quarter trading update, he told investors that he expected to see "a recovery in cruise ticket prices beginning in the second quarter of 2013." Arison also said that "a measured pace of new builds" would enable the company to generate "significant excess free cash flow", which would be returned to shareholders.

I do not think that Carnival is a good buy for a retirement portfolio at present -- its short-term outlook is uncertain and its 2.5% yield is below the FTSE 100 average, while its shares look expensive to me. What's more, I am confident that there are far more attractive FTSE 100 shares available for retirement investors, some of which feature in the report I mention below.

Top income picks

Doing your own research is important, but another good way of identifying great dividend-paying shares is to study the choices of successful professional investors.

One of the most successful income investors currently working in the City is fund manager Neil Woodford, who manages more money for private investors than any other City manager. Neil Woodford's High Income fund grew by 342% in the 15 years to June 2012, during which time the FTSE All-Share index managed a gain of only 125%.

You can learn about Neil Woodford's top holdings and how he generates such fantastic returns in this free Motley Fool report. Many of Mr Woodford's choices look like excellent retirement shares to me and the report explains how he chose some of his biggest holdings.

This report is completely free and I strongly recommend you download "8 Shares Held By Britain's Super Investor" today, as it is available for a limited time only.

> Roland does not own shares in Carnival.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.